
Practice areaAppellate Litigation
Great Falls & Montana Appellate Lawyers: Civil Appeals, Montana Supreme Court Appeals and Ninth Circuit Appeals
Boland Aarab PLLP.
Our attorneys: Caitlin Boland Aarab · Samir F. Aarab
As Montana appellate lawyers, we give clients one piece of advice first: the clock is short. In most Montana civil cases, a notice of appeal must be filed within 30 days, and an appeal can only fix errors that were properly raised at trial. We handle appeals to the Montana Supreme Court and the Ninth Circuit, and we defend verdicts on appeal.
Key Takeaways
- Montana civil appeals: file the notice of appeal within 30 days of entry of judgment, or 60 days when the State, the United States or a local government is a party. Where notice of entry of judgment must be served, the clock starts on service (M. R. App. P. 4(5)(a)).
- Federal appeals to the Ninth Circuit: generally 30 days after entry of judgment, or 60 when the United States is a party (Fed. R. App. P. 4(a)(1)).
- Timely post-trial motions (new trial, judgment as a matter of law, altered findings) restart the Montana appeal clock (M. R. App. P. 4(5)(a)(v)).
- The Montana Supreme Court generally will not consider an issue raised for the first time on appeal (Unified Industries, Inc. v. Easley, 1998 MT 145, ¶ 15). Appeals are won or lost at trial.
On this page: Montana Supreme Court appeals · Deadlines · Ninth Circuit appeals · Standards of review · Preserving error · Defending a verdict · When to call · Why Boland Aarab · FAQ
Facing an appeal, or need to protect a verdict? Contact Boland Aarab PLLP for a free consultation at (406) 315-3737.
How does an appeal to the Montana Supreme Court work?
An appeal from a Montana district court goes straight to the Montana Supreme Court. It starts with a notice of appeal filed with the Clerk of the Supreme Court, with the filing fee, and served on the district court clerk and every party (M. R. App. P. 4(2)). A timely notice is required to give the Court jurisdiction over the appeal.
The basic steps are:
- A final judgment. Most appeals must wait for a final judgment, one that settles all the claims, including costs and attorney fees (Rule 4(1)(a)). A district court can certify a partial judgment as final under M. R. Civ. P. 54(b), and the Supreme Court reviews that certification before the appeal goes forward (Rule 4(4)(b)).
- The notice of appeal. It names the parties and the judgment or order appealed. An appeal from a judgment “draws into question all previous orders and rulings excepted or objected to which led up to and resulted in the judgment” (Rule 4(4)(a)).
- Appellate mediation. Appeals in cases seeking money damages are subject to mandatory appellate mediation (M. R. App. P. 7(2)(c)). The notice of appeal must certify whether the appeal is subject to it.
- The record and briefs. The Court decides the case on the district court record: the pleadings, exhibits and transcripts. The briefs frame the issues and the standard of review.
- Decision. Many appeals are decided on the briefs without oral argument. The Court may affirm, reverse, or reverse and remand for further proceedings or a new trial.
How long do you have to appeal in Montana?
In most civil cases, 30 days. The rule gives 30 days from entry of the judgment or order to file the notice of appeal, and 60 days when the United States, the State of Montana, a political subdivision, or one of their officers or agencies is a party. When notice of entry of judgment must be served under M. R. Civ. P. 77(d), the time does not begin until that notice is served (M. R. App. P. 4(5)(a)(i)).
Other timing rules matter:
- Cross-appeals. Once one party files a timely notice of appeal, any other party may cross-appeal within 15 days, or within the original time, whichever is later (Rule 4(5)(a)(iv)).
- Post-trial motions. A timely motion for judgment under Rule 50(b), to amend findings under Rule 52(b), to alter or amend or for a new trial under Rule 59, or for relief under Rule 60(b) restarts the clock. The time runs from the order deciding the motion, or from when it is deemed denied at the end of the 60-day period in M. R. Civ. P. 59(f) (Rule 4(5)(a)(v)).
- Premature notices. A notice filed before the court rules on costs and attorney fees may be dismissed (Rule 4(5)(a)(iii)).
Criminal appeals follow different deadlines. Do not rely on a general rule. Get advice on your case’s exact date the day the judgment is entered.
How do federal appeals to the Ninth Circuit work?
Cases decided in the U.S. District Court for the District of Montana are appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. The notice of appeal is filed with the district court clerk, generally within 30 days after entry of judgment, or 60 days if the United States or a federal agency or officer is a party (Fed. R. App. P. 4(a)(1)).
Ninth Circuit practice differs from Montana practice in ways that matter. Briefing follows the federal and circuit rules. A three-judge panel decides the appeal, and argued cases are heard in the circuit’s courthouses in cities such as Seattle and Portland. Federal courts also have their own preservation rules. For example, a party that wants an appeals court to review whether the evidence was sufficient for a jury verdict must renew its motion for judgment as a matter of law after the verdict under Federal Rule 50(b) (Unitherm Food Systems, Inc. v. Swift-Eckrich, Inc., 546 U.S. 394 (2006)).
Samir Aarab has argued twice before the Ninth Circuit.
What will the appeals court actually review?
An appeal is not a new trial. The appellate court reviews the record for legal error, and how closely it looks depends on the standard of review:
| Standard | What it applies to | How much deference |
|---|
| De novo | Questions of law, such as the meaning of a statute or rule, and summary judgment | None; the court decides the question fresh |
| Clearly erroneous | Findings of fact made by a judge after a bench trial | High; findings stand unless clearly wrong (Fed. R. Civ. P. 52(a)(6)) |
| Abuse of discretion | Evidence rulings, trial management, new-trial orders | High; the ruling stands unless it was outside the range of reasonable choices |
| Substantial evidence | Jury verdicts | Very high; the verdict stands if the evidence reasonably supports it |
Our own cases show how this works. In Voegel v. Salsbery, the Court reviewed a new-trial order for “manifest abuse of discretion” and reviewed the legal meaning of the evidence rule on insurance de novo (2023 MT 137, ¶ 12). In Konesky v. Keller, the Court reviewed a summary judgment de novo and reversed it.
Choosing the right standard, and arguing within it, is often the difference between winning and losing an appeal.
How do you preserve an issue for appeal?
By raising it clearly, on the record, at the right time in the trial court. The Montana Supreme Court will not address an issue raised for the first time on appeal or a party’s change in legal theory, because it is “fundamentally unfair to fault the trial court for failing to rule correctly on an issue it was never given the opportunity to consider” (Unified Industries, Inc. v. Easley, 1998 MT 145, ¶ 15).
In practice, preservation means:
- Object, and say why. A ruling admitting evidence can be challenged on appeal only if a timely objection or motion to strike appears of record, stating the specific ground unless it was obvious (M. R. Evid. 103(a)(1)).
- Make an offer of proof. When evidence is excluded, the substance of what would have been shown must be made known to the court (M. R. Evid. 103(a)(2)).
- Get rulings on motions in limine and renew objections where the ruling was tentative.
- Propose and object to jury instructions on the record, with the specific grounds.
- Move for judgment as a matter of law at the close of evidence and renew it after the verdict, where the evidence is insufficient.
- File the right post-trial motions on time, because they can both fix errors and set the appeal clock.
- Make sure the record is complete: transcripts, exhibits, sidebar conferences and rulings.
Plain error, an exception for serious unpreserved errors, exists (M. R. Evid. 103(d)), but no one should plan a case around it. This is why we try cases with the appeal in mind.
Can a verdict be protected on appeal?
Yes. A winning party’s job on appeal is to show that the trial was fair, the rulings were within the court’s discretion and the verdict is supported by the evidence.
That is what happened in Voegel v. Salsbery. After a rear-end crash in Malta, a Phillips County jury returned a $168,500 verdict for our client. The district court later granted the defense a new trial over a statement in closing argument. We appealed. The Montana Supreme Court reversed the new-trial order and ordered the verdict and judgment reinstated (Voegel v. Salsbery, 2023 MT 137; case result).
Appeals also correct rulings that end a case too early. In Konesky v. Keller, a Cascade County legal-malpractice case, the district court granted summary judgment for the law firm defendants. The Montana Supreme Court reversed and sent the case back, holding that an undisputed attorney-client relationship is sufficient to establish the lawyer’s duty of care and that ruling on breach before the expert-disclosure deadlines was premature (Konesky v. Keller, 2021 MT 214N). The win on appeal is what put the case in front of a jury. In December 2022, a Cascade County jury returned a $100,000 legal malpractice verdict against the law firm, Church, Harris, Johnson & Williams, and $388,291 against the buyer of our client’s ranch: $488,291 in all (read the full story).
When should you bring in appellate counsel?
Earlier than most people think:
- Before trial, to plan motions in limine, jury instructions and the record.
- During trial, to handle objections, offers of proof and motions for judgment.
- Right after the verdict, to evaluate post-trial motions, which have short deadlines of their own and control the appeal clock.
- As soon as judgment is entered, because the notice of appeal deadline is 30 days in most civil cases.
- When the other side appeals, to defend the verdict and consider a cross-appeal within 15 days.
We handle appeals in cases we tried and cases other lawyers tried. We work with trial counsel or take over the appeal.
The Boland Aarab Way
We are trial lawyers who try cases as if they will be appealed, and appellate lawyers who know what happens in a courtroom. We see our cases through to the end. Our appellate record shows how:
- We know the Montana Supreme Court. Our attorneys have handled more than 40 Montana Supreme Court matters since 2017. The Boland Aarab appellate record reaches back to 1977.
- We protect verdicts and reverse bad rulings. Voegel v. Salsbery, 2023 MT 137, reinstated a jury verdict. Konesky v. Keller, 2021 MT 214N, reversed a summary judgment, and the jury on remand returned a malpractice verdict against a Great Falls law firm.
- We know federal court. Samir Aarab has argued twice before the Ninth Circuit, and our attorneys have handled more than 40 cases in the U.S. District Court for the District of Montana over the past nine years.
- We try cases. Our firm has tried more than a dozen jury trials, in Cascade, Phillips, Meagher and Yellowstone Counties, and our attorneys have spent more than 4,000 hours in the courtroom. We know what a preserved record looks like because we build them.
- We are part of the profession. Both attorneys are members of the American Association for Justice and the Montana Trial Lawyers Association. Caitlin Boland Aarab is an AAJ Governor and serves on the MTLA Board. Samir Aarab is also a member of Public Justice.
See our results.
Contact Boland Aarab PLLP for a free consultation at (406) 315-3737.
Where do we handle appeals?
Our office is at 18 6th Street North, Suite 200, in Great Falls. We handle appeals to the Montana Supreme Court from district courts across the state, including Great Falls, Billings, Missoula, Helena, Bozeman, Butte and Kalispell, and appeals from the District of Montana to the Ninth Circuit.
Appeals cases across Montana
We are based in Great Falls and handle appeals cases statewide. Local information for each city:
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do I have to appeal a civil judgment in Montana? Generally 30 days from entry of the judgment, or 60 days if the State, the United States or a local government is a party (M. R. App. P. 4(5)(a)). If notice of entry of judgment must be served, the time runs from service.
Can I appeal because I think the jury got it wrong? Usually not on that basis alone. Appeals courts review legal errors, and they uphold a jury verdict that the evidence reasonably supports.
Can I raise a new argument on appeal? Generally no. The Montana Supreme Court will not address issues raised for the first time on appeal or a change in legal theory (Unified Industries v. Easley, 1998 MT 145).
Does filing a post-trial motion change my appeal deadline? Yes. Timely motions under Rules 50(b), 52(b), 59 or 60(b) restart the Montana appeal clock, which then runs from the ruling on the motion or its deemed denial (M. R. App. P. 4(5)(a)(v)).
How long does a Montana Supreme Court appeal take? It varies with the record, briefing, mediation and whether the Court hears argument. Plan on many months, not weeks.
Do I need a new lawyer for my appeal? Not necessarily. Many clients keep their trial lawyer and add appellate counsel. We handle appeals in cases we tried and in cases tried by others.
What is the deadline to appeal to the Ninth Circuit? Generally 30 days after entry of judgment, or 60 days if the United States or a federal agency or officer is a party (Fed. R. App. P. 4(a)(1)).
Can the other side appeal after I win? Yes. We defend verdicts on appeal, as in Voegel v. Salsbery, 2023 MT 137, where the Montana Supreme Court reinstated our client’s jury verdict.
Talk to a Montana Appellate Lawyer
Contact Boland Aarab PLLP for a free consultation at (406) 315-3737.
Sources: M. R. App. P. 4 · M. R. App. P. 7 · M. R. Evid. 103 · Fed. R. App. P. 4 · Fed. R. Civ. P. 52 · Unified Industries, Inc. v. Easley, 1998 MT 145 · Voegel v. Salsbery, 2023 MT 137 · Konesky v. Keller, 2021 MT 214N · Unitherm Food Systems, Inc. v. Swift-Eckrich, Inc., 546 U.S. 394 (2006)
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.